Comments: For the Vox Populi: A Comparison of How Some Blog Aggregation and RSS Search Tools Work

Mary,

Very interesting post, and a good clarification of how different services work. We (Technorati) actually have the aggregate link counts in our databases, and we could show them if people think that this is an interesting statistic, but what we've found is that using it for ranking or other authority calculation is problematic, because it becomes a very easy thing to game - many links (e.g. a robot posting multiple times linking to your blog) may inflate your counts arbitrarily, and by definition, these counts will always increase, giving significant deference and near-gentrification to bloggers who have been around for a long time. I don't think that we really want that. Of course, no system is perfect, but we're trying to keep our authority rankings pretty relevant - thus the focus on links from the blog homepage making a difference in the rankings.

As soon as I get a chance I'll write more about this on my blog, but it will be interesting to hear what other people think about this practice, our goal is to be of service...

Dave

Posted by David Sifry at July 25, 2005 07:49 AM

This is good stuff. I'll link to it tonight.

Posted by Robert Scoble at July 25, 2005 01:53 PM

Love to hear what you think of kbcafe.com search.

http://www.kbcafe.com/search.aspx

Posted by Randy Charles Morin at July 25, 2005 01:56 PM

Great write up. Tough job since those services are evolvng every day it seems.

Posted by jim wilde at July 31, 2005 01:16 PM

This is hugely valuable for those of us in the PR business trying to sort out what to tell our cilents. Thank you so much for putting this together Mary!

Posted by Lisa Poulson at August 1, 2005 03:55 PM

What about the blog search by Technorati?

Posted by sodora search at September 10, 2005 03:19 PM

does this thing work?

Posted by test at September 10, 2005 03:20 PM

Quo Vadis, Technorati? Down the drain?

The search result for interface translation at Technorati

www.technorati.com/search/interface+translation

renders, disappointingly:
#
Latina street latin translation, latina ass...

Latina street latin translation, latina ass latina pussy. Algeria Interface - Nov 15 10:50 PM Latina street latin translation, latina ass latina pussy.Save to My Web

* Posted 5 hours ago in big saggy tits 0 links Search this blog

#
ADSL配置静态IP的配置参考

timestamps log uptime ! hostname 827 ! ip subnet-zero no ip domain-lookup ! bridge irb ! interface... address and it's a private IP address. ! interface ATM0 no ip address no atm ilmi-keepalive pvc 0/35 encapsulation aal5snap ! bundle-enable dsl operating-mode auto bridge-group 1 ! interface BVI1 ip

* Posted 5 hours ago in 像鸟儿飞ア  0 links Search this blog

#
THE MATADOR de Richard Shepard (USA-2005): en...

nouvelle interface, de nouvelles options, etc... En principe, tout cela est de la cuisine interne, et..., quelques bugs se sont glissés dans cette nouvelle interface! L'adresse email du Dr Devo (moi!), soit... collier, moins collé monté que LOST IN TRANSLATION, par exemple, autre film d'hôtel et d'ennui, à

Posted by Gisela Strauss at November 18, 2005 12:47 PM

Mary, this review about different blog search services very interesting. And thanks for footnotes. Too it is a lot of helpful information. I have read also PDF file of comparison of how Blog search work. Thanks for your work!

Posted by Bruce at December 9, 2005 02:11 PM

I am new to all this and this has been very useful for me. Many thanks Mary, keep up the good work, all the best from Jim.

Posted by Jim Rockingham at March 15, 2006 12:51 PM